Both real sheepskin and synthetic fleece can both work for lining western saddle skirts. The best choice depends on climate, maintenance willingness, budget, and how much you value cushioning versus ease of care.
Pros and cons
- Real sheepskin
- Pros: excellent cushioning, true moisture absorption, breathable, traditional premium look/feel.
- Cons: more expensive, heavier, requires careful cleaning and drying, can harbor odor/bacteria if not kept dry, can shed fibers and stiffen if not cared for properly.
- Synthetic fleece (faux shearling)
- Pros: usually cheaper, lighter, easier to clean, dries quickly, resists odor buildup if kept clean.
- Cons: can be less breathable or less plush depending on quality, may not absorb moisture as well as real wool, some riders feel it doesn’t wear in as nicely as sheepskin.
Key considerations for your decision
- Climate and horse comfort
- Hot/humid climates or horses that sweat heavily: high-quality synthetic fleece that wicks and dries quickly can be easier to manage but prone to loosing its loft.
- Cooler climates or riders who like extra warmth/cushion: real sheepskin can be very comfortable and insulating.
- sheepskin retains its loft and padding acting as a barrier between the saddle tree and your horses back.
- Maintenance willingness
- Real sheepskin needs regular cleaning (specialized shampoo, air-drying, brushing) and careful storage.
- Synthetic fleece is much more forgiving and easier to wash.
- Durability and use
- Real sheepskin can last a long time with proper care but may wear faster if exposed to rough conditions or frequent washing.
- Synthetic fleece often withstands frequent washing better and keeps its look with less maintenance with a shorter lifespan.
- Budget and availability
- Real sheepskin is pricier; high-quality synthetic options are more affordable and readily available.
Practical care tips
- Real sheepskin
- Clean with a sheepskin-safe shampoo; use cold or lukewarm water.
- Rinse thoroughly; squeeze out excess water gently (don’t wring).
- Air dry away from direct heat or sun; brush lightly to restore fluff.
- Avoid hot water, high heat, and repeated quick washes that can make the wool stiff or shrink.
- Synthetic fleece.
- Air dry; avoid high heat to prevent shrinkage or damage.
- No fabric softeners unless the product specifically says it’s OK.